When Thomas and I have his wooden railway out, normally the trains do go from one place to another, even if it's between just two stations. We must, deep down, enjoy see our trains as having a purpose. The problem is, most of us just don't have too much room available for our little trains. There are things we can do to fit more in - smaller scale, tighter curves, shorter trains, etc., etc... But sometimes things can just look a bit too busy.
There are other options which won't make things appeare compressed or compromised for a smaller space. A smaller scale is an obvious thing to consider - too often though, people pick N gauge and then pack in so much it just looks silly and toy like. But used carefully, the smaller scales can give a feeling of space in a relatively small area - combined with the right prototype, the results can be very good indeed. Chee Tor is perhaps one of the finest model railways ever built and it shows how well a smaller scale can be used to convey the feeling of space, and it wasn't as big as it looked either.
Go further and combine these advantages with the idea if a layout showing a journey and a smaller scale can really achieve big things. Have a look at some of the N gauge schemes which appear in Kalmbach's Model Railroad Planning and you'll see just how good things can look. Some of the 'sincere' plans (where the route will pass through each scene only once) are superb.
In a similar style, I sketched this plan when I was a teenager. I assume it was sized to fit a room at my parents' house, but I can't remember now! Nothing came of it, but I was attempting to model a couple of bits of the Malton & Driffield Railway during my teens in 2mm Finescale. It wasn't an overly succesful venture but I did learn an awful lot, especially about building track. The line itself is a favourite of mine - a ridiculous scheme which didn't really achieve anything it set out to do but set in one of the loveliest parts of Yorkshire, deep within the Yorkshire Wolds, diving underneath them at Burdale. Today the whole area is still unspoilt and largely ignored by visitors who pass along the main road to the much busier moors to the north. But there is a group working towards reestablishing the line - please do have a look at the Yorkshire Wolds Railway's site!
|This was my teenage attempt at modelling Settrington in 2mm Finescale. The trackwork was mostly completed on this and the adjoining North Grimston. All that's missing here are the coal drops and the road leading to it. It worked too! The one item of motive power which was completed was a J27 based around a Nu-Cast kit. This was intended for the Farish 94XX chassis which I rewheeled with wheels from Neil Ballentine who used to prodce drop in wheel conversions for RTR Farish models. The wheels were a world away from the Farish originals (though not so much with the more recent Farish releases) and it felt like I was really getting somewhere with 'finescale'! It ran ok, but the pick ups I fitted to the replacement PCB keeper plate were probably not the best... I did produce a small selection of stock but this was the only loco which was appropriate for the line - for someone used to 4mm and 00, it was a whole new world of wagons. Some easily converted with replacement wheels and others built from the 2mm Scale Association's wonderful range of kits. I suspect this had quite an effect on me for how I've approached things later on in P4. I had a lovely Fraish Std 4 2-6-4t with Neil Ballentine wheels which looked very nice and I still have it somewhere. It was probably one of the better Poole era steam locos produced by Graham Fairsh and with the new wheels, really looked the part. I think I had ideas about a Whitby area based branch line! I might not have finished anything in 2mmFS, but I did learn an awful lot.|
I part built models of Settrington and North Grimston stations, most of the track was completed but scenically the schemes never reached completion at all - fields mostly remained plywood coloured. The remains are still stored in a cupboard at my oldies' houes... Both stations would make excellent subjects for layouts in a number of scales. I intended to build Settrington in P4 for the Scalefour Society's 1883 Challenge but I think with uni and detailing and respraying diesels for people I just didn't have the time. A shame really. Worringly I did sketch out a scheme for Settrington in S7...
The idea of one train meandering along the Malton & Driffield would have suited single person operation. In later years a pick up goods would be the only trains the branch usually saw by the end of its life. the plan does give an option of working trains from Burdale back towards Malton, and is sited so these would traverse virtually the whole length of the layout too. There are issues with the plan; both Settrington and north grimston have been placed so they're viewed from 'the wrong side' as they would be better view from the outside. Settrington could be on the plan if you ducked under. The should also be a distinctive viaduct between the two stations which would be best added as it was a very obvious feature to passing motorists. I actually like how Burdale is presented but the biggest omission is Wharrem! This was one of the larger locations on the line and very distinctive with the quarry by the station and the stone silo still visible today. however the site would require a fair bit of room, which is, I presume, why I omitted it. Regardless of the mistakes and issues, I still think the line would make a rather nice system to model.
Yorkshire Wolds Railway